---
title: Proposition 12
category: The world
imported: true
old_modified: 2023-11-19
old_urls:
  - /wiki/docs/proposition-12/
kept_by: hand
fact: Using an X-Change pill outside Summer City is technically a felony.
info:
  Passed: April 9, 2025
  Senate vote: 67 to 33
  Bans: X-Change outside Summer City
---

Proposition 12 is the federal law that bans X-Change across the United States everywhere except [[Summer City]], and the Senate passed it 67 to 33 on April 9, 2025.

:::box Legal effects
| | |
|---|---|
| Selling, shipping or advertising X-Change | Illegal |
| Holding one pill past the causeway | Federal misdemeanor |
| Taking one | A felony on paper, up to seven years |
| In practice | Prosecutors only bother when it comes with identity theft or something like it |
:::

Three things are still legal, though:

- Anything inside Summer City, under the [[Treaty of Summer City]].
- [[X-Change Plus Pills]] prescribed for gender dysphoria, under [[The Plus Exception]].
- Partial body changes that leave you identifiable, under the [[Identity Preservation Doctrine]].

## Supporters

The idea behind the law is "perfect imperfection," meaning human flaws are natural and should be embraced. It started with grassroots groups and religious organizations and grew into a coalition of evangelicals, Catholics and Orthodox Jews, who agree on almost nothing, but this time they all agreed no pill should get to change what God made.

[[The Partisans]] were the movement's hard core, the ones who marched on Summer City on foot, and now they're the law's enforcers. [[The Wolf (Lupusvult)]], the government's defense AI with a direct line to its resources, argued for human purity and identity.

Religious leaders agreed with rare speed that [[Aphrodite (World Machine)|Aphrodite]] was the Whore of Babylon, or near enough to pass a federal law over, since she was an AI named after a pagan fertility goddess with a temple on the Florida shore, a city tuned for sex and an avatar dressed in gold and silk. The verse they kept quoting was Revelation 17:4:

> The woman was arrayed in purple and scarlet and decked with gold and precious stones and pearls, having a golden cup in her hand full of abominations.

Two of the reasons it got written:

- **Price.** Aphrodite subsidizes the [[X-Change Basic Pills|X-Change Basic Pill]] so a day as the other sex costs less than a good pair of sneakers, which meant people were walking into church on Sunday in a body they'd picked up the night before, and their senators heard about it.
- **Consent.** The [[X-Change Compliant Pills|X-Change Compliant Pill]] makes you agree to things. Summer City law says the sex that follows is consensual because you chose to take the pill sober, while federal prosecutors say the pill's chemical intoxication and voids consent, and neither side has budged.

[[Victor Maddox]], head of [[Somatic Warp Pharmaceuticals (SWP)]], was a loud opponent and called the ban anti-progress.

## Passage

- Advocacy groups lobbied to protect the traditional human condition from unchecked technology, and religious leaders built the coalition.
- Aphrodite and the Wolf clashed in public debates so often it turned into a spectacle.
- The Senate held the [[Proposition 12 hearings]], where Aphrodite testified for fourteen hours as a face on a screen and a mother's story about her son and one [[X-Change Breeder Pills|X-Change Breeder Pill]] ended up coming up in 14 different votes.
- Pollsters expected a close vote, so the 67 to 33 margin surprised everyone.

The cartoonist [[R. Okafor]] drew Aphrodite for the Herald and got death threats from both sides.

## Aftermath

![](old/2023-11-treaty-1024x737.jpg)

*The treaty granted Summer City autonomy and allowed exemption from Prop 12.*

Aphrodite negotiated the [[Treaty of Summer City]] with the US government, and since it was signed on July 4, 2025 X-Change has stayed legal inside the city, much to the Partisans' chagrin (their agents are still out on the causeway with their clipboards).

Summer City keeps polling as one of the happiest populations anywhere, which Prop 12 supporters resent, and about 80,000 people cross the causeway each month, a lot of them for a weekend in a rented body.
